The Day That James Died
Aaron Scobie
“Give me a quote,” said Wade.
“What?” I said.
“From your little book there. Give
me a quote.”
I’ve been coming to Corner Hole
Coffee a lot recently. Usually when I come in here I have a book of some
variant with me. It use to be thick textbooks and laptops all the time, but
I’ve moved on past all of that. I am finishing my time at school here and it
seems the closer I get to graduation the more intellectual applications of
literature, or “books that make ya a smartass” like Nanny Ree says, arise
weekly. The more I read and the more I think about “big words” and
“smarty-pants phrases” the less I want to use them.
“A quote?”
“Jesus, John, it isn’t that
difficult.”
I held up the book and read the cover Dubliners by James Joyce. It was a
collection of his short stories. I had just bought it the other day so by this
time I hadn’t even started reading it. To be honest I shouldn’t have been
reading it at all. I had gotten behind in my readings for a lot of my classes
and my stubbornness to not use any online summaries was beginning to fade. I
flipped a few pages, mostly introduction or some other BS about Joyce that I
didn’t care about. I stopped on the first page. I made a quick glance at Wade
and saw him patiently waiting for me to reply. His eyes were locked on the book
in this sort of half strain: his attempt at reading the back-cover. I am a
terribly slow reader. The feeling of impatience came over me as I began to scan
the page for a unique word or something that stood out. There were a few things
italicized but finally decided on the word “paralysis”.
“Every night as I gazed up at the window
I said softly to myself the word paralysis.”
A beam of sweat coasted along my face
like a greasy water slide. It had only been somewhere close to maybe half a
minute before I said it. I thought it was a good quote at the time and I did
say it in this weird tone. I think I was trying to seem like an intellect. The
way I thought Joyce would say it. I quickly realized how absurd the line
sounded. I felt a few more streams of sweat slide down my face converging
together creating a sort of alluvial fan.
“Interesting,” Wade said.
“Ha! Really?” I said.
“Yeah, totally.”
I knew that he was lying. Wade was good
about making his customers feel welcomed and homey. He always talked to
everyone who would order from him and even more so to those who sat at the bar.
After six Wade would open up the beer taps and start to serve alcohol. I
remember that more and more places started to serve alcohol. I recall an old
roommate I had back then thought I was so absurd that coffee shops would serve
alcohol. Corner Hole only served one brand of beer. Wade knew the guy who ran
the brewery and got really good deals on the mini kegs he would buy.
“Hey Wade. Do you mind if pour me a
Scotch Ale.”
“Sure.”
Wade still hadn’t gotten the hang of pouring
beer yet. You have to tilt the glass and kind of rotate back and forth. And as
the beer got closer to the top you would even the glass out in a more vertical
stance. I had looked back at my book and in order to try and figure out what it
was about in case Wade would ask me more about it. I read the first line,
“There was no hope for him this time: it was the third stroke.”
“Damn.”
I sat at that bar for a good long while.
Wade and the other barista knew me fairly well, or rather more so than most of
the customers that came in. I was a regular. Whenever Wade would close he did
that really cheesy thing where he would play “Closing Time” to get rid of the
people that liked to linger. I was trying to finish that first short story when
Wade cranked it up real loud. I remember getting anxious. My eyes flew across
the words to the point where I only got bits and pieces of the sentences I
read. I remember Wade looking at me and telling me to take my time and that I
didn’t have to leave. It was at that moment I felt like I was part of this ‘in’
crowd: this crowd who I saw as the “cool crowd” which was stupid because we
were all adults. I was twenty-one at the time, Wade was about to push thirty
and the other barista, I think her name was Sarah, had to at least be
twenty-two or something. That song just blared that night. I could hear the
conversations that circled around me: Wade and Sarah talking about the
significance of Closing Time and how
it was not about alcoholism and how it was really about the singer sneaking in
a song about his kid. The band got mad at him and gave him this ultimatum that
he had to stop writing about his kid, he agreed but this limiting of his creative
writing introduced him to the ability to be more secretive creative
consciousness. The other conversation, I recall, was between two girls in large
sweatshirts with the delta gamma logo embedded on them. They were talking about
how one of them sang this song at karaoke the previous night. Wade and Sarah
conversation made me think about what Mike Kinsella had said in a interview. He
said that before he had a kid, all of his music was about failing at
understanding relationships and that that’s what he thought music, and in that,
life was about. I was sipping beer while all of this was going on. Mike Kinsella
said that when he became a dad that all of his thoughts shifted from music to
being a dad. Oh how monotonous. I finished my beer and decided to go home. When
I walked outside I pulled my phone out. At the time a buddy of mine and gotten
me into this app, whose name alludes me at the moment, but you could log in
your beer and basically show off to everyone in the area how cool you were and
how cool your taste in craft beer was. I went to go log in my scotch ale and
whenever I was about to hit “Confirm Brew?” I decided to write a comment about
it. I had never written one before, and even after this I still never wrote
one. But this time I had decided to write one. I must have really wanted
everyone to understand how I wanted them to see how I felt:
“It’s Thursday, my uncle died today and I’m
reading Joyce. Events like that can make a beer taste special.”
I only had two classes that day. I was in
my senior year at Georgia Southern as I made sure to only have a few class a
day. This semester I remember I had to have all my classes in the morning. Normally
I would of had a class at noon but it got canceled. The two I had were both morning
classes. Nanny had been pestering me about coming down back to Clayhatchee for
a few days now:
“Johnny, now it’s important that you call
me as soon as you get done with class,” she said.
“I know Nanny,” I replied.
“Don’t get smart. This is important ok.
When do you get done with class today?”
“I get done around 1 on Fridays.
“When do you plan on leaving?”
“Probably 2ish I think.”
“Good, good.”
“Yeah.”
“…”
“Hey…hello?
“I’m still here Nanny.”
“Cut the tone ok. Now listen to me
alright, Johnny?”
“What?”
“Johnny…”
“What?”
“Thank you sweety. Now listen, when you
get down here I don’t want you acting like your current self alright?”
“What are you talking about?”
“You know what I mean. I want you to be
humble when you come down here.”
“Of course I’m going to be humble Nanny.
What made you think about that.”
“Well last time you came down here, you
know that early Christmas dinner we had? JoAnne brought to my attention how bad
your attitude can be at times.”
“What on Earth are you talking about? I
got snooty because she started making gay jokes about me. She was being a bitch
and you were just letting her get away with it.”
“Hey! Shut up. You don’t talk to me like
that alright mister?”
“…”
“Now JoAnne informed me that I made a
wrong comment about something and you corrected me and started to sort of make
fun of me in doing so.”
“Nanny if I did I’m sorry but I—
“Johnny, listen, please. I know you’ve
been at that school of yours for a few years now and I know that ever since you
switched majors, a lot of your likes and dislikes changed. You changed quite a
lot. But even in all of that, I still know you’re my John boy and I love you
very much but if you act like your current self, I gonna cut you off
financially a lot sooner than you’d like. Are we clear?”
“…”
“John Raskols are we clear?”
“Yes ma’am,” I replied.
“Good. I have to go now. Some of the
ladies from Church are coming up from Coffee Springs and they want to talk
about the arrangements for Saturday.”
“Is the memorial going to be in Coffee
Springs?”
“Yes…”
“Alright. I gotta go Nanny. I love you.”
“Love you too sweety. Don’t forget to
call me when you leave.”
“I won’t. Bye.”
“Bye-bye.”
Southern folk love to gossip and love to
talk about each other’s families. They also love to talk about children, or
well in Nanny Ree’s case grandchildren. I only remember JoAnne very briefly but
I remember that dinner very well. Nanny was talking about politics and more so
talking about dumb news she had heard during her “Older Singles” small group at
church. JoAnne was usually the one to lead the charge of who to bash that day
and to my knowledge Nanny would usually keep to herself just nodding her head
and adding some ‘mmhmms’ here and there. She was never one to avidly speak
poorly on someone unless she felt justified in her actions. That’s how she
would put it at least. I would get daily phone calls from her telling me about
someone from church and how this person did this one thing or did something to
someone or with someone. She would always tell me how proud she was that I
decided to take the ‘smart adult’ path and go to college. However, JoAnne
always had some snooty little chime to say about me. As I advanced in years the
more and more she grew to dislike me. I think it was because I called her an
old hag. I remember really hating myself after I said it and I apologized but
she was one of those people who seemed to think that if she wasn’t upset then
the universe was out of flux and looked to pick someone apart and be angry. I
guess it wasn’t too hard for me to get on her ‘bitch about’ list.
“You’re a little shit, you know that
boy?” JoAnne said.
“Oh piss off. You would have found
something to be pissed at me about,” I replied. “I just made your job easier.
“You don’t deserve the grace that Ree
gives you.”
“Well at least I don’t fill her head with
hate and nonsense,” I said.
“Well, I do hold her back.”
“What?”
“You hold her back,” JoAnne said. “In her
eyes you are still a child.”
“What does that have to do with
anything?”
“She is 67 and is still trying to act
like a new mother. Your inability to grow into your age is damaging her health.
Her thought that you still need to be helped is increasing her stress level.
Your constant asking for money is showing everyone how much of a child you
still are. You told everyone last time you came down that you finally got a job
how you felt you were becoming an adult. Fuck you. You are a child. You have
always been a child. You need to realize that becoming an adult takes a lot
more than just going to college and getting a dead end job.”
Just as I had gotten out of my last class
that day when I got a phone call from my boss asking if I could come into work.
I think it was because one of the other staff leaders at the theater who was
suppose to close that night quit. I remember him really begging me to come in.
If I didn’t come in that means that he had to actually take charge and direct
people around. He was really bad at telling people what to do. I had already
packed my bag and was about to leave. It was only 10:38 and I had figured it
was better to get on the road early seeing as I had a four-hour drive ahead of
me. My boss had been waited impatiently on the other end of the line when I
began to think about not going to Clayhatchee. I use lie to Nanny Ree all the
time in college. Usually it was about what I doing (which was probably
drinking) or I’d tell her some BS about why I couldn’t come down a weekend when
she wanted to see me. I knew it would look terrible to my family but I really didn’t
care then. At that point in my life I felt as though Tillis, Toree, Jack,
Jamie, and all of their kids weren’t family to me anymore. They were just
people who shared the same last name as me or had the same blood as me. My boss
once again pleating for me to come in had cut off my thought:
“Johnny please come in. Where short
staffed as it is.”
“…I can’t Bennet. Not today.”
“And why the f—“
I think he also quit that weekend. Maybe
JoAnne was right.
I had decided to just get up and go. I
wasn’t going to tell anybody I was leaving or why. I was just going to go. It
was weird that drive. Usually on Friday, traffic was awful and the four hours
seemed like I would have an eternal ache in my right ankle from the constant
stopping and going of have to deal with lunch rush in Georgia. But that day,
that day there was only two cars between I-85 and me. I remember verbally
expressing my disbelief in what I was seeing. I decided that I wasn’t going to
listen to the radio for a while. I had wanted to just stay in the silence of
wind. It was a rather warm day that ended that February. I think it was in the
high sixties, low seventies. I always had the window rolled down in that car
because it drained my gas if I ran any sort of hot or cold air. I remember
sitting, thinking about what I was going to say and how I was going to act at
Jim’s memorial. The drive began to trip me out because there were at least two
moments were I was in the left lane and I didn’t remember changing lanes or
what I was thinking about. It scared me for some reason. I kept thinking about
how time had moved so fast that semester and I really desperately wanted it to
slow down. I became terrified of the fact that the real world was creeping up
on a much more stagnant pace than I had myself. All of my friends I had made in
college, all the relationships I had, all the love interests I had, everything
was going to end. I remember thinking:
“Is this what it means to be an adult? To
give up everything I hold near and dear to me in my heart? To give up all the
people I cared about? Where I and only I would tell all the memories I have?
Only me. No more going to bars and laughing with Gusto’s of thick stouts. No
more getting into fights with my friends over trivial shit. No more fun. Is
this why Tillis and Toree, and the South for that matter, decide so early on to
get married and have kids? So they too don’t have to feel the weight of age
creep over their skin? So that they might distract their minds with the happiness
of their own children? So that they might have a chance to live again like the children
they have? And hopefully their children, when old enough, will have children
early enough to have grandchildren and spoil them? And so on and so on and so
on? Do I need to wait? Should I just deal with the girls I can get with and who
I know I could marry easily?”
My thoughts back then seemed to only be
flooded with questions, which constantly kept asking more questions as to help
shape the previous questions. I thought I was being forced to grow up so quick
that I wasn’t able to enjoy the time I did have to be happy. When I had just
gotten through Enterprise I got a phone call from Nanny:
“Hey sweety have you left yet?”
“Yeah I left a long time ago”
“Where are you?” she asked.
“Just outside Enterprise, I should be at
the trailer in half an hour.”
“Oh…well wonderful.”
“What?” I asked.
“Well, I just would have liked to know
you were going to be here sooner. I would have had a chance to clean up
quicker.”
“Are you mad?”
“No, no, no”
“…”
“Hey, you still there?”
“Yeah.”
“JoAnne is going to be staying with us
this weekend and also going up to Coffee Springs with us tomorrow.”
“What, why?”
“Because Johnny, she has been helping me
with a lot of stuff and it doesn’t matter. She is staying in your room so
you’ll have to sleep on the couch.”
“Nanny!”
“Hey!” she said.
“…”
That was the worst thing I ever did
to Nanny. I hung up the phone after that conversation. I’m sure she understood
but back then I had such a hot head and was ‘going through a lot’. I never
realized how much Nanny was hurting that weekend. I guess it hadn’t registered
with me that Jim meant a lot to Nanny. Even though he was just a stepson from
her first marriage, he was still the closest thing she had to family back then.
He was the only child she had left.
That first night I didn’t spend a
lot of time with Nanny and JoAnne. I think I talked to Nanny for two or three
hours about how school was going and how life was going and how I recently been
wanting to become a writer. JoAnne had gotten a kick out of that. I feel as
though if I were to see her today she would give me the same spill about how I
will get nowhere as a writer and that I should stick to my theater day job and
hope to die as a manager. After that I drove to Dothan to see my friends who
never made it out. We had spent to night out on the town. I only told Jake, my
best friend at the time, that my uncle had died. I remember not wanting
everyone to feel bad for me and putting a damper on the night. I think we went
to a sports bar called ‘Alabama Slammer’. I had wine and everyone else had
Coors or Bud Lite. I think I should’ve just stuck with beer that night but
something in me just wanted to show off my pseudo-intellectualism and maturity.
I was a dick back then. After laughing about dumb stuff we did in high school,
I had ordered everyone a shot of Fireball and gave a toast:
“Here’s to good friends, good
memories, and good futures.”
I have always hated Fireball but
back then it was the only thing anyone ever drank when it came to shots. I
probably shouldn’t have driven home that night but I didn’t care. Back then the
urge to get wasted and make poor decisions and drive home seemed to overtake my
mind. The desire of wanting to be in control took over all rational thought and
reason I was capable of back then. I thought that that was what it meant to
have fun when you were in college. I thought that if you weren’t doing those
things then you would miss out of what was defined as the ‘best years of my
life’. Oh how cliché.
We drove Nanny’s Jeep to Coffee
Springs that next morning. I can’t remember how bad my hangover was but it was
enough to where I made all three of us stop at Starbucks in Enterprise. I hated
Starbucks solely on the fact that they were a chain coffee establishment and
also they had bad coffee. While I was getting coffee I kept telling Nanny and
JoAnne ways Starbucks was bad. I went into vast detail about why you shouldn’t
double roast beans and also shouldn’t mix the roasts. I told her just because
the coffee stays warm doesn’t mean it’s fresh. I think it was mostly the
hangover but I was being a terrible snob about everything and everyone that
morning and at a certain point in the line, JoAnne had enough and called me out
in front of the whole line. I think it was then that I thought she was the
first person I had ever really hated. The only bad thing about it was that this
time she was justified in having the attitude she did. As she had argued with
me I realized my actions. It was at that point that I realized that no matter
what I do this woman will always hate me in return. This woman will never like
me and this woman will do everything in her power to make me look like a fool.
When we were in that Starbucks, it wasn’t until Nanny had said:
“Johnny will you please stop it!
This day is not about you.”
I had walked back to the car after
that. I didn’t even wait to get my coffee. I don’t even remember if I Nanny Ree
had brought my coffee to the car. I think she wanted to but JoAnne just threw
it away before they left the store. The car ride after that was quiet. I think
I had disrupted the mood for there to be anything of valuable conversation. The
drive from Clayhatchee to Coffee Springs was close to an hour and after you hit
Enterprise it’s nothing but woods and miles of field. It is a farmer’s
dreamland. A few things had caught me eye as we made our way to the memorial.
Just as we left Clayhatchee, there was an even smaller town just before you hit
the county road. I don’t think that town even has a name but aside from the
handful of homes, I saw there was one store, a convenience named ‘Annie’s
Convenience Stor ‘. The gas there was a dollar more than anything in the city
was.
“Nanny why is the gas so much more
here?”
“It’s the country sweety. That’s how
things are.”
We went back to being quiet again
after that. The other thing was just outside Enterprise. It was this little
cabin that had above the door the name ‘Enterprise School of Massage’. After
that was just nice country with old homes and new cars. It was so weird seeing
all that. I remember thinking that southern people so desperately try to preserve
tradition and the ‘old look and feel’ to things that they don’t progress with
the times or at least they don’t on an internal level. Every home it seemed
like, and even to this day, has the contrast of chrome cars and moldy brick
homes. It had distracted me from the road the whole way there. When we had
finally gotten to the memorial it was in that dead town of Coffee Springs. The
memorial was at what seemed like at the time, the only functioning building
aside from residential homes. It was called the ‘Coffee Springs Joy and Life
Center’.
I had never been to a memorial
service before this one. I didn’t know how they were supposed to go. People had
filed in in pairs and groups and the women of the family had been preparing a
late lunch. Once the thing started Jamie had gone up first and talked and then
Nanny went and then other people from church went up and talked. I remember
that everything everyone was saying about Jim seemed to be good things.
Actually everything they said were good things. Jim wasn’t that good of a man. I
had kept quiet every time someone asked the audience if anybody else wanted to
talk. Looking back I remember a few people kept giving me a quick glances
seeing if I was going to talk. I never wanted to be there let alone talk. All
of my cousins had there three or four kids, none of them over the age of
thirteen at the time, running around and talking and playing with the fake
flowers in the center of the scratchy white tables while this was going on. I
had begun to think about what JoAnne said about me being a kid. I know at the
time I never would have said this but in some distorted way it was some of the
best advice someone could have given me. I remember looking around at my family
and thinking:
“Is this what it means to be an
adult, being 32 and pregnant with my fourth child? Or being the husband at the
age of 34 and wanting more because I can’t cope with anything other than having
children? Not wanting to grow up just yet. This can’t be what it means to be an
adult. It just can’t. It can’t. It can’t.”
After the memorial, I had been
waiting for Nanny Ree to get done saying goodbye to everyone when Tillis had
come up to say good-bye:
“Well cousin, I guess this is
good-bye,” he said.
“I guess so.”
“Hopefully next time it will be in a
happier setting.”
“Yeah,” I said.
“You make sure to do good in school
alright?”
“I will.”
“I mean it. Everyone here, even Jim
was. We’re all proud of you.”
“…”
“You know,” Tillis said, “you are
the first Raskols to go to college.”
“…”
“Come here. Get in close now.”
“…”
“Don’t be like us, alright. You have the
chance to make something of yourself.”
“…”
“I love you buddy.”
ReplyDeleteYou know I like the first scene. It has a tone and poignancy that works for a beginning and for this character and is an effective contrast to where the story ends up going. I thought that it was in interesting thing to have this person’s grandmother telling him not to be himself, and for that notion to eventually be validated, in a way. The simplistic Disneyist advice of “be yourself” is not the universal key that it purports to be. Also, the last name…Raskols…don’t know if it works realistically in a story like this but definitely keep it in anyway for Dostoyevsky’s sake. John should be thankful if hanging up is the worst thing that he has ever done to his grandmother. The paragraph that follows that note, though, is very good. It seems true and real that he would forget these things, and that they would come to him at this moment, and that they would hurt, and propel him to some moral reflection and action. While it is incredibly difficult to read, I think that I like the idea of him being a coffee snob to his mourning family members. Because, if not written here, where else could I read that? Also, “Jim wasn’t that good of a man.” That hit hard. Even without context, that’s big, Maybe expand on that notion.
I think that I see some resonance of Joyce’s ideas about paralysis in the work, but would hope to see more. Read Evelyn and The Dead if you haven’t already. We’ll talk. I had trouble pinning down the narrative perspective here—from where is this character telling this story? I haven’t specified in my work, but you have this curiously conversational language alongside so many phrases like “I was a dick back then,” and “the name alludes me at the moment.” These sorts of editorializing moments are a detriment, I think, to the journey of your character. The way that Nordan does it, as well as some of the anthologized authors that we have read, is less deflating and more expanding and complicating. The conversation with JoAnne, obviously intended to be harsh, was just distractingly vicious. I am not saying that it cannot work, I am saying that it needs to be justified and contextualized more. Her last rant about John’s condition reads, to me, like an overly neat summary of the issues at hand in the story. He says that college has been happy, but it seems that he is striving to stay there just to continue to be unhappy, which would be perhaps more interesting and would only require some minor wording changes. Acknowledging clichés does not cancel out the use of clichés, I think, and a direct rumination on something as broad and debated as “adulthood” as an idea could really benefit from some more cultivated and narrowed terming from your narrator. Lastly, you are doing something intentional with the “…” repetitions. I wonder if it comes from your current reading of Brief Interviews. I am not sure it works here in this more conventional form, but I could be proven wrong with some justification, because some moments of its use felt right.
Wallace as an inspiration for a story like this could really do wonders. If I were you, I would look closely at Adult World (I) from BIWHM and Good Old Neon from Oblivion. Not for his experimental form, (I think that you are right in wanting your story not to delve into that,) but in his insight into self-conscious young-person psychology and the existential angst dealt with therein.
I think you have several things working really well in this story. The details in the first scene (the drinking, the social anxiety) is shown to have powerful roots in the narrator’s past experiences and past life in his hometown. There are several moments of really beautiful language that stood out especially, like “feel the weight of age creep over their skin” and “a farmer’s dreamland.” The invocation of Joyce and the concept of paralysis is really powerful, and I think you could do more with that. I think you could find a more elegant opening though, since Wade isn’t really a major character and the opening bit isn’t so significant for the rest of the story.
ReplyDeleteThere are just a couple key things I’d recommend in revision, several of which other people have mentioned/will probably mention. The perspective or vantage point from which Johnny is telling the story is unclear. Phrases like “back then I had such a hot head and was ‘going through a lot’” and “I was a dick back then” distance the narrator from the narrative and are confusing to read. This goes along with the pattern of Johnny commenting on his own memories and experiences in a way that distracts from the events themselves, like saying things like “Oh how cliché.” There is a nice irony of JoAnne, an adult, being so nasty and immature, but the conversations between her and Johnny feel unnecessarily brutal. There are several lines, especially in that conversation that feel too direct, like they’re telling exactly what you mean to get across, like “Your inability to grow into your age is damaging her health,” for example. I think the story would benefit from the reader seeing Johnny receive the news of his uncle’s death and his reaction to the initial news, and expounding more on the dissonance between the image people construct of him at the funeral and his actual character.
Your writing feels a lot stronger in this story than in your first. On top of that, the protagonist and his conflict feel more alive. I think part of this may be that I identify with this two-world struggle in a way, but I think even without that your story pulls readers in. You have strong focus on this conflict and how it affects his relationships with his family. However, I think you can improve on how this conflict relates to the end. As for now, your ending is genuinely sad and trenchant in its understanding of the complex struggle. However, I’m wondering what the ending means for him? How does it change him? He’s left with the same conflict he had in the beginning of the story, only now the tension is stronger: his family loves him more for his ambitions (at least his collegiate ones). Don’t get me wrong, this is great, and I admire this moment a hell of a lot. But what comes next? How does John’s life change? You may intend your story to be tragic, leaving john in a more deeper pit than he was initially in, but consider showing a way out of this, showing reconciliation in some way. What does John feel toward Tillis and his family at the end that might make his conflict, in the least, something beautiful? If this isn’t making sense, as me after class.
ReplyDeleteWe talked earlier about your formal experimentation. The alternation between dialogue and paragraphs is tough to perceive here because the much of the dialogue isn’t very long. It stands out when he’s on the phone with Nanny, but that’s the longest patch of dialogue. Even if this was apparent though, I’m unsure what the purpose is. Is it anything more than experimentation for the
sake of experimentation?
Here are some notes I took I think you’ll find useful:
Be careful with hyperbole (he always talked…) & vague phrases (knew him fairly well; a good long while)
The Closing Time quirk is great. It’s funny and you draw the perfect amount of attention to it.
Consider suggesting earlier that his uncle has died. It seemed a little sudden when it came out. Maybe just suggest it briefly in a line of dialogue to prepare readers.
You've got some really nice, specific details here that add a lot of character to your story, like the coffee shop that turns into a bar, the "Closing Time" song, and the beer app. I liked that that was how you let readers know that his uncle had died. It came as a shock, but I felt it was early enough in the story that it was okay.
ReplyDeleteI really like your theme. As a graduating senior, I can totally relate to trying to figure out what I'm going to do with my life, and how my concept of being an "adult" seems to drastically change as I get older. However, I think these problems should occur more organically throughout the story. Maybe his uncle's death makes him begin to evaluate his own life in comparison to his Uncle's. I often find myself looking around at other people and looking at their professions and if I could see myself doing that, much like what he does at the memorial service with his relatives. I think death itself is a really natural starting point for this and you may not need to lead into it so explicitly.
I think you've created a really interesting family dynamic here, and that it needs to be flushed out. I think it would help if you cut down the number of family members, or referred to the less important ones by title (brother, aunt, etc.) instead of by name. I also think you should flesh out the characters and their relationships more. Nanny and JoAnne seem to be mostly one-dimensional right now. I can tell there's a history with Nanny, that she seems to be his primary caretaker, and I want to know more. What happened to his parents? As for JoAnne, she seems nasty without any reason to be, and I want to know why she is so angry at him (jelaousy?).
I think you should describe the town of Clayhatchee more. I had a hard time picturing it. Also, the scene with the friends and the drinking didn't seem to contribute to the rest of the story.
One last thing that Emma touched on as well, was that I was curious where the main character is telling this story from. I can tell that it is far in the future, but I think you should be more clear about when.
I really like your first scene. You were detailed but you also had a goo mix of dialogue and exposition blended throughout. I think that was the best scene in your "coming of age?" story. I do also need to know how far removed he is from the events he's recollecting because it almost seems to get farther and farther away as you read along.
ReplyDeleteI also want to know how old Joanne is? I also think for revision a good place for you to create conflict and tension would be in the starbucks scene. Maybe have you and joanna going at it and his nanny's trying to hush them before she can't take the bickering anymore.
You nailed it with the heart of the story. I love the different characters' differing definitions on what it means to be grown up and you are successful in showing the character wrestle with these ideas and you force the reader to ask the same question, what does it mean to grow up. The first scene is by far your strongest, it felt the most real to me and then the rest of the story seems to lack the specificity of setting that the first scene was successful in having.
ReplyDeleteYou made some interesting stylistic decisions, particularly with dialogue and I don't think that it's working NOW but it CAN. In some scenes, like the first scene, dialogue is done in standard form. In other scenes, particularly phone calls, dialogue is done in a highly stylalized, unique way. I think this style can work, you've just got to go for it more. Go all in and let this style take over your whole story, rather than just portions of it.
Really enjoyed the story!
Aaron, I’m seeing a vast improvement in your writing between your first story and this one. The word phrasing and dialect have greatly improved, and there is a greater focus overall. The characters are more rounded, and better realized this time around. I think the Uncle’s death should perhaps be used as a starting point for why the main character is thinking about fully becoming an adult. Life is short, and the time to make something of himself is coming. I think there should be a tighter focus on that.
ReplyDeleteRegarding your concerns, I think that you should go back and maybe consider looking over your flow of both description and dialogue. Both work hand in hand to create a picture of what is happening both internally and externally. I think that simply “having enough dialogue” is necessarily the right way to go about writing your scenes. Go back and think about what dialogue and description is relevant to the story, and is not there just to take up space, although I know that is not the intention. There are bits that can be taken out, there are moments that could be expanded, and there are moments that would benefit from change without disrupting the flow as it is. Overall, you’re doing a good job, man.