Demons and Wasps
Authors Notes: The thing that I wish I could have done better was bring out the heart of the story which was the main character realizing that he does live a sheltered life and that the people who are in his life aren't helping him grow up but instead holding him down. I feel that at times the story gets too predictable and cheesy while other times i feel that emotion takes over and is written well but the cheesy/predictable overshadow those. This story is based on a lot of different things but none deal with the three memory exercise we did in class.
Addition to this: I realize there is a good bit of melodrama at the end and I just wanted to point out that I realize I seriously need to change the ending so any help on that would be great.
Authors Notes: The thing that I wish I could have done better was bring out the heart of the story which was the main character realizing that he does live a sheltered life and that the people who are in his life aren't helping him grow up but instead holding him down. I feel that at times the story gets too predictable and cheesy while other times i feel that emotion takes over and is written well but the cheesy/predictable overshadow those. This story is based on a lot of different things but none deal with the three memory exercise we did in class.
Addition to this: I realize there is a good bit of melodrama at the end and I just wanted to point out that I realize I seriously need to change the ending so any help on that would be great.
When
I was sixteen, my cousin and me spend the better part of an afternoon trying to
take out a nasty wasp nest in my Uncle Jim’s unfinished home. Jim was building
a little house for himself behind my house. You see Jim and his son, my cousin,
Joseph, we just called him Joey; we all lived with my grandmother, Nanny Ree. I
was there on account of not having any parent. Well I had my dad; mom die when
I was born, and daddy left when I was two. Now the reason why Jim and Joey are
there is because well Jim’s wife Marsha ran off one day. Just got up and left
all her things and ditched town. Jim told the police that she had to have been
kidnapped but Nanny Ree didn’t think it for one second.
So
there we were, Joey and me. We were standing very calmly, staring at the nest.
I’m not sure what Joey was thinking or if he was even looking at the nest but I
was. I was like the ones we get on the wooden porch Jim built last year. It was
exposed and vulnerable to all outside forces. You could see all the secret
little passages the wasps would creep in and out of. “What do we do Johnny?”
“I’m
not to sure Joey.” I glanced down at my cheap velcro watch and saw that it
wasn’t even ten thirty yet. I let out a loud grunt leaning my head to the
ceiling and stomped my foot. “Jeezus John, relax.” Joey said. He grabbed my
arm. “We gots to treat this situation carefully. If you just go ona stompin’
around them wasps is gonna come after us.” Joey was still grabbing my arm. I
exhaled a deep breath and lowered my head. I glanced at his arm. Why was he still grabbing me? I felt his
fingers tremble. His nails were yellow and his veins were exposed. Joey saw me
staring and threw his arms behind his back. “So yeah Johnny boy, what are we
going to do.”
“Exactly
what you said,” I replied, “treat the situation carefully.” We had to treat the
wasps with respect.
I remember that morning being woken
up to the sound of Jim yelling at Nanny. It had something to do with Jim
wanting to work on the house today. I don’t know why they were arguing. I
thought Nanny Ree wanted to Jim to finish building that dang old house.
I
stretched my legs with a very deep frown on my face. It was Saturday. I hate
Saturdays. Saturdays meant that I had to figure out a way to preoccupy my time
for twenty-four hours because my options were limited on what there was to do.
I live in Clayhatchee, Alabama; population: 237. Well around that. We always
get some new military person due to the town being so close to Fort Rucker.
In
the town with a population of 237, there are a handful of things I get to do. I
can ride my bike to the church that is about two to three miles down the rode.
I could ride my bike to go see Muhammad, the tiny Indian man who ran the only
gas station in town. If I did that I could rent a couple of movies or buy a
moon pie and RC cola. Or I could go exploring. I could go find that old Volkswagen
Truck way deep in the woods behind my house or I could follow the stream next
to my Great Aunt Jessie’s house.
When I finally sat up and started to
wipe away the eye potatoes from the corners of my eyes, I just let out a big
sigh. I look over at wind-up alarm clock and saw that it was 7:36. This meant
that my morning of finding something to do was extended. I never can go back to
sleep once I’m up. Not even if it’s two in the morning.
I
looked around the tiny unfinished house. It was like the wasp nest in a way. It
was so open and vulnerable. The only walls that had been built were exterior
walls and the walls to the bathroom in the back left corner. I shouldn’t say
that the exterior walls are actually walls. They are more like foundation or
whatever you call it. It was that yellow insolation stuff I think. It
surrounded the outside with it. It was this mucus yellow color. It was very
durable. You could slide your finger across it make little designs, kind of
like on a suede couch. Joey and I would draw very poor pictures of dicks and
other crude drawings. His uncle would always go behind with a brush or
something and erase them.
I look over at that bathroom and its
closed door. I stare at it. I just stare. I wasn’t even sure Joey had saw me
staring at it. I prayed he didn’t. I just stared and stared and then stared
some more. I could here Joey rummaging around behind me. It sounded like he was
look for something. Not breaking my stare I ask, “Joey what are you looking
for?”
“A pole or stick or somethin. Quit
yer lally gaggin and help me.”
“Ok.” I didn’t move.
When I hopped off the bed this
morning, I did my usual routine and walk into the bathroom across the hall from
my bedroom. I let out a deep sigh as I begin my ritual of picking up after Jim
and Joey. All three of us share a bathroom even though there are two in the
trailer. We don’t use the other because it is in Nanny Ree’s poor man’s master
bedroom. Well she calls it that. It is the exact same size as the other
bedrooms but someone just attached a bigger bathroom on the side. Sometimes
when no one is home Nanny Ree will let me shower in her bathroom but she knows
how bad ours is. She treats me so well. She is a kind gentle soul and treats
everyone with same sweet southern hospitality. The only person I can remember
her not treating kindly with that down home kindness is my poor old daddy.
Nanny Ree puts it, “That man is a no good piece of shit who don’t want no part
of you Johnny.” I’ve never met the man so I can’t say if he is or not but I
always replied with, “Yes ma’am, I know Nanny,” and I’d go about my day. I shut
the door to the bathroom and shut the door. I pick up the clothes and toss them
in the teeny-tiny clothes hamper that sat between the toilet and the sink. It
was fun because I would pretend I was playing basketball and pretend to jump
shot the balled up button ups. I would miss most of the time, which was pretty
sad, but I’d just laugh it off. I would always stare at myself in the mirror
when I did this. On days like today, where my morning starts off kind of
crappy, I would find Jim’s underwear on the floor. They would always be in the
same spot, slightly caught on the rusty pipes tucked away behind the toilet. I
always hated when he did this. They would be soaking wet as if he got in the
shower and forgot to take them off. Like duh! Come on Uncle Jimmy. To top it
all off I couldn’t tell what was rust and was poop. It didn’t help that he wore
whitey tighties. I get so mad that I want just stop my feet and yell bad words.
I started to clinch my fist in the plaid and squeeze my eyelids super tight.
But then I remember what Nanny Ree told me to do when I get like this. She
would say, “Johnny whenever you get so angry and you just wanna blow ya lid
like a tea kettle, just think of me, and think of how I treat everyone; even
those mean ol’ folks down the field. I treat them just as kindly as any nice
church lady. So whenever you get mad just think of me and think of how I treat
people.” I opened my eyes and unclenched my fist. I threw the plaid button up
in the hamper and made it on my first shot.
I was surprised that Joey hadn’t
yelled at me again to help him find his stick. In the twenty to thirty some odd
minutes I stood there he didn’t say a word after that first question. I stared
at the door to the bathroom and began to notice the to shape of it and its
features. It was a long skinny door. A fat man would have trouble getting
through but he could make it. It was one of those boors that the two columns of
smaller rectangles in it but this door only had one column. The door was bone
white, which for some reason stood out to me. It was the one thing is this run
down piece of crap place that my uncle kept up. I’m guessing due to all the
paint cans scattered about, that this is where Jim goes when he tells Nanny Ree
that he is going to work on the house. I can’t be mad at him for not actually
working on the house. The love of his life did leave him and their son so who
am I to judge. I may have never had a woman I could love like that but still
you expect a man to just move on with his life after something like that. Can
you?
I finally started to move toward the
door. I didn’t make my stare I just got nervous about Joey looking at me
staring at this door. I had the rummaging finally stop and turned around behind
me to see what was happening. “Hmm…what’s the matter JoJo?”
“What are you doin ova there?”
“What are you talkin about?”
“You know what I’m talkin about why
you staring in that corner? You was suppose to be helping me find a stick to
knock this nest down.”
“I was just staring at a bee,” I
said. I was good at lying. Or at least making him believe I did.
“Bullshit,” Joey said. I tightened
up. I never did like the ideas of cuss words and they always made me feel funny
in my stomach. Joey knew this too. “What’s the matter? Afraid of a little
fuckin cussin?”
“Joey stop it you know I don’t like
those words.”
“They ain’t that bad come on just
say one.”
“No they’re bad. Brother Lance told
me that when someone cusses that they are sinnin. He tells me that I should
even say poop because it is so close to a cuss word. It like it’s a cuss words
cousin.”
“Bullshit,” Joey said starting to laugh.
I think he did that just to make me mad.
“I’m serious!”
“Come on Johnny, just say one. We’ll
start out easy, just say ass. Aaaassssssss. Come on. Say it. Ass.”
“I don’t want to.”
“John just say it!” Whenever Joey
yells at me I want to curl up into a ball. I know I’m suppose to love him
because I’m family to him I just never can make myself feel it. He always does
this. He makes me say uncomfortable things and gets me in trouble. He knows how
much I hate cussing. His dad always helps me. Its like he knows how mean his
son is and just doesn’t care anymore. It’s like after Marsha ran off he gave up
on his son. But he always talks to me and is nice and everything else like
that.
I start to cry. “Oh now don’t go on
a crying.”
“Well you know how much I don’t like
those words Joey.”
“Johnny its just one word. What’s
the big deal?”
“It’s a sin.”
“Bullshit it’s a sin. That man
Brother who-the-fuck-knows is just an ass clown and just tryin to brain wash
you and all them kids to teaches at that tiny ass church just like his daddy
brain washed him. I can’t stand people like that. People like that are worse
than the niggers who don’t gots no jobs and expect government handouts. Fuck
that. Fuck them niggers. Fuck that church. Fuck that Brother man. And fuck you
for fallin into that dumb shit.”
“Shut up! Just shut up!” I have both
of my fist clinched and my whole body tensed up. I grabbed the nearest paint
bucket, closed my eyes and flung it at where I thought Joey was. I really
started crying now. I’m panting. There was a brief half-minute where nothing
happened. I hear footsteps running. I open my eyes and see Joey rushing at me.
What’s happening? Did I hit him? I see any paint on him. Oh God. I brace for
the tackle I feel is inevitable. Then I feel something grab my arm. I flash my
eyes open and it’s Joey pulling me toward the front door. My legs don’t
recognize that we’re running from the cloud of wasps. Their nest seems to be
covered in paint. My legs connected with my eyes and start to run. My eyes are
still staring at the nest and the cloud coming towards us. Finely my brain
realizes the situation and I let out an incredible screech that my halfway down
puberty voice can make. We get to the door and I feel Joey lift me and throw me
out the door. I was flying. Time seemed to slow down and I waited for the
ground to press against my face. I was watching Joey slam the door and throw
his arm in the air. The back of my head hits the ground and I hear a yell. I
guess Joey got stung. I guess you get what you deserve.
When Jim first started building the
house, it was right after Marsha had left him and Joey. Jim put all his time
and effort into that house. Nanny Ree would tell me that he was working his
sorrows out into that house. Jim starting going to church and made Joey go as
well. Joey hated it. Joey and Brother Lance would always go at it about
everything. Brother Lance couldn’t read a verse without Joey making some
smart-aleck remark.
After
about three months Jim received a phone call from the lead detective saying
they think they might have found Marsha. Jim was so ecstatic. The detective
said that they would know for certain for a few more days. At least that’s what
Jim told us. Nanny Ree told Joey and me to go to our rooms so that Jim could
have his phone call in peace. I went to my room but I kept an ear to the door
but I couldn’t hear anything on account that the doors and walls in this
trailer were like lead when it came to listening. Joey liked this. Joey had a
girlfriend. I didn’t cause I was nosey.
This
was about and a half ago. I remember cracking the door open and seeing Jim
sitting with his head in his left arm and in his right hand was phone. He was
holding it above his neck. I remember hearing some like of noise from him but
it was muffled due to his head being in his arm. I remembered Nanny Ree seeing
my door open and I remember her saggy arm waving at me to close the door. I
didn’t know what was going on I just remember that after that day for the next
month Jim was the nicest man I had ever seen. He was constantly getting on to
Joey to be nicer to me. He also was trying to get Joey more involved with
church and brother Lance. All that seemed to come out of that was Joey being
quieter and didn’t fight with Jim as much. Jim saw this as a solution and kept
the routine up.
Once
this month was up news came to the rest of the family. Marsha was dead. She was
killed by some homicidal manic or kidnapped or anything like that. She died in
a car accident with her new husband. However I wasn’t told this. I was told
that she hit a deer and wasn’t wearing her seatbelt and wasn’t being a safe
driver. No one wanted to tell me what was really going on and to this day I
still don’t know why.
I
remember her funeral. I remember there being a lot of tears and a lot hugging.
I also remember there being a lot of tension. Specifically between Jim and this
man named Richard. He had a funny accent. I remember them arguing but every
time I got close enough to actually listen to what they were saying some women
who was a friend of the family would pull me away.
After
the funeral we all went to Larry’s Barbeque in Daleville. Somehow the family
managed to rent out the entire building for a few hours. Everyone chatted and
laughed and cried and had a good time. When it came time for everyone to go.
Joey, Jim, Nanny Ree, and me all piled in Nanny Ree’s car and drove back to our
trailer. No one said a word on the entire ride back. I kept looking at their
faces, except Nanny Ree’s, she was in the driver’s seat, and there was no expression.
We finally got back to the trailer and I ran up to the porch and went inside.
Joey was the first to come in. He went straight to his room and turned his
music on. It was so load that you could actually hear it through all the doors
and walls that separated the living room and his room.
I
kept waiting for Nanny Ree and Jim to come inside but they never did. I went to
the window and saw them arguing. I couldn’t make out what but it had something
to do with the car keys. Finally, I remember Nanny Ree just throwing the keys
at Jim and stomping up the stairs. Her fists were clinched too. She came
stomping inside.
I
remember saying, “Nanny, are you ok?”
I
remember her saying, “Yes dear. Just…I love you very much.”
She
kissed me on my forehead. I heard the sound of and engine belt squealing. It
remember standing on the porch playing with the Velcro on my watch as Jim drove
down or long, bumpy, dirt rode. He drove the car into a ditch that night.
I
opened my eyes squinting at the sun and his rays. “Joey, what the heck?”
“Oh
shit Johnny, are you ok?”
“Yeah,
yeah I’m fine. What happened?”
“You
threw a paint can at me you little shit.”
“Well
why on earth did you throw me out the house.”
“Oh,”
Joey chuckled, “you missed me by a long shot and hit that damn wasps nest.”
Joey
really started laughing at me now. I sat up and brushed the dirt off my shorts.
I started to rub at the new grass stains that are now permanently stuck to my
shorts.
“Hey
now,” said Nanny Ree, “is you boys being careful?”
We
collectively reply, “Yes ma’am.”
“Alright
well would you boys like to have some lunch? I juss got done cookin some stew.”
“We’ll
be there in a minute, Nanny Ree.” Joey said.
Nanny
Ree walked back into the trailer. I watched Joey crack the door open. He
motioned for me to come over to him.
“Look
what you done did Johnny.”
On
the entire far sidewall, wasps were littered everywhere.
“We
can’t tell Nanny Ree about this, ok?
“Ok.”
I said.
We
went into the trailer and sat down for lunch. Nanny Ree had made some Brunswick
stew with cheese in it. She added cheese to everything. It seemed like she adds
cheese to everything. I wanted to ask her why she always added cheese to things
but I kept my mouth shut. Nanny Ree always told to keep my questionable
thoughts to myself and if they were serious enough to pray able them. I wasn’t
going to pray about this because it was just cheese. I just don’t understand.
Then out of nowhere Joey asks, “Nanny Ree, why do you always put cheese in
every god dang thing you cook?”
“Because
Joseph, cheese is good for you.”
“What?
Where on Earth did you hear that?” said Joseph.
“In
one of my magazines.”
“You
need to stop reading those. They just like to fill yer head with pointless
knowledge.”
“Well
at least I read something Joey. I swear I feel like all yous do is just sit in
your room and listen to that dumb crybaby music.”
“It
isn’t crybaby music!” He said as he slammed his hands on the table and stared
at Nanny Ree.
“Are
you two fightin about cheese again?”
“Hey
Uncle Jim.” I said.
“Hey
Johnny.” He patted my head
Joey
closed his eyes for a second and took a deep breath. He opened his eyes and
paused for a second. “May I have a spoon Nanny Ree?”
“Sure.”
She handed him on of those big tablespoons.
“May
I have a normal spoon?”
“Nope.
I already lost to many of them.”
Jim
asked, “Joey did you Johnny take care of those wasps?”
“No
dad we didn’t. Me and John over here started horsen around some how managed to
knock somethin heavy into it.”
Jim
said, “Well shit.” I glared at him. He didn’t see me. “Well I was about to head
to the store to get some nails and maybe a new belt, a can pick up some wasp
killer while I’m out”
“What
do you need a new belt for?” I said.
Jim
said, “Well my other one broke and—“
“How’d
it break?”
Jim
said, “I just did. God you are so nosey today?”
I
got up and ran to my room. I could hear Nanny Ree scolding him and Jim arguing
back. I cracked open the door to hear what they were saying.
Jim
said, “You can’t keep treating that boy like he’s a damn five year old Mom.”
“Dad’s
right Nanny Ree.” Joey said, “The boy just near about seventeen.”
“Hush
both of you. I will treat that boy have ever I please. Now go get your damn
belt Jim!” I’ve never heard Nanny Ree cuss. I closed my door. What are they
talking about? I sat in my bed and looked at my hands. I looked up and around
my room. I saw all my posters littered with cartoons and on my shelves all my
Rescue Hero toys and all my Disney VHS tapes. I went up to my Ed, Edd, n’ Eddy
poster and just stood in front of it. I clinched my fist and closed my eyes.
“Remember Johnny whenever you get so angry and you just wanna blow ya lid like
a tea kettle, just think of me, and think of how I treat everyone; even those
mean ol’ folks down the field. I treat them just as kindly as any nice church
lady. So whenever you get mad just think of me and think of how I treat
people.”
“Ahh!”
I punched a hole in the wall right through the middle of the poster. I was
breathing heavily now, panting almost. I heard the chairs screech and footsteps.
My door was still cracked. “Johnny are you ok?” Nanny Ree yelled. I slammed my
door and locked the on the knob and the chain. I ran to my window and opened
it. I stood there clueless and finally just kicked a hole through the thin
screen. I stuck one leg through the exposed screen. I could hear muffled voices
and multiple hands pounding on my door. I jumped out the window. I hit the
ground hard.
Man
our trailer is tall. I looked around. I can’t run into the woods they’ll just
call the cops and find me. I could…
I
back door flung open and I saw Jim and Joey running out towards me. Nanny Ree
was in the doorframe yelling something like “Johnny don’t” and “Come back,
please!” I looked at the unfinished house with its mucus yellow walls and ran.
I ran and ran as fast as my sixteen-year-old legs would let me. I ran to the
top of the steps and at the door I turned around behind me saw Jim and Joey
very closed. I flung open the door and ran inside.
I
paused in the center of the open exposed room. I heard Jim yell, “Joey, get the
boy before he hurts himself.” I realized that I wasn’t alone in the house. I
hadn’t realized until just as Joey got in the doorframe that this house was
filled with wasps. I looked at Joey.
Joey
said, “Johnny why don’t you juss come on out of here now. I don’t know what you
heard but me and Jim didn’t mean it.”
I
stand there. I can’t think. I don’t want to go back with them. Not now. I
grabbed a paint can. I look at Joey and say, “Fuck you.” I threw the pain can
at the wasp’s nest hitting it square center. The wasps started buzzing and
swarming at Joey and me. I run to the bathroom in the exposed open house and
slam the door. I locked the door and just stood there. Two wasps snuck in with
me. I grabbed the top to the toilet and start swinging at the two wasps. Once I
killed both of them I sat on the toilet and cried. I stand up and go to put the
lid back on the toilet. I look inside and see a hand full of syringes and burnt spoons and a broken belt.
“I
had better tell Nanny Ree I found her spoons.”
There are a lot of things working really well in this story, and this is a huge improvement from your stories from Fiction I! Really well done. One of the best aspects of this story is the strength of the setting. You’ve filled Clayhatchee with lots of strong details and characters–one way to show this strength would be to have the speaker interact with the setting and a character outside the family. One of the biggest issues I had with this story is the inconsistencies in verb tense. The majority of the story seems to be in past tense, but there are frequent instances when it lapses into present tense. The first time this happens is in the first paragraph (“Now the reason why Jim and Joey are there…”). A similar issue is the fact that, several times, there are two speakers within the same paragraph. This would just be a small issue, except for the fact that all the names of the characters are so similar, as they all begin with Js, that I had to go back several times and check who was who. Maybe changing a few names to differentiate the characters would help. Another structural issue is the timing of the scenes: the story begins with the speaker and Joey in the unfinished house, then goes back to the speaker waking up that morning. It then repeats that same pattern again in the next scene (or what I’m guessing is a scene division, given the space separating the sections). I think I get your intent with making the scenes non-sequential, but it just got too confusing. I don’t think that the backstory of Martha’s disappearance and death is necessary for the story. We don’t know enough about Martha, or Martha and Jim’s relationship, for the news of her death to have much of an impact. Those scenes could be better served seeing the family interact, or learning more about the speaker.
ReplyDeleteThis story has some very nice elements going strong here. I like your setting in this story and it feels authentic with the help of your characters, their names, the vernacular and syntax employed. I feel it is overall your strongest point. There are however, some areas for improvement or questions that I have about your story. There are some things that are confusing or don't seem to add up. I was first confused about the age of your speaker. You state that he is sixteen years old, but he reads so much younger than that on the page; I don't know if that is intentional or not. I also would like to know what causes Johnny to get angry and jump out of the window. That scene left me puzzled because it seems like nothing really triggers his anger. There are a Lot of grammatical errors that pull away from your story and make it hard to read (just a tip for the next time). I don't know if we really see a character arc, and if there is one, then it needs to be better defined. I also would like to know the importance of the last drug abuse scene. It felt out of place.
ReplyDeleteAaron,
ReplyDeleteYour story’s voice is strong from the beginning. I enjoyed this for most of the story and thought it was a strong point. At times, though, you overdo it. Same with some dialogue. Remember in Spell’s class when we discussed using syntax rather than abnormal spellings to portray accents/versions of English. Otherwise, it added a lot of character to your narrator. One worry, though, is that the voice is so authoritative that the narrator doesn’t come off as sheltered. The cussing stuff, which felt like the first true sign of innocence, felt almost out of character for me. To resolve this, you can change to third person, bring up marks of shelteredness earlier, or tone down the voice. I’d advise trying the first two before the third, since the voice added a lot of character to your story.
I understand your concern about the heart of your story, but I think first you need to reassess your story’s lowercase aboutness. Your story’s trajectory is close to feeling complete because the wasp nest and house stay present; however, the front of your story seems all about the wasp nest, and the back seems to deal heavily with Uncle Jim’s problems and the narrator’s discovery. Though the wasp nest plays a role in the plot, it seems like the characters are ultimately more important. The wasp nest seems secondary. I think this is important because it will help you (1) focus your story around the characters (introducing them first, portraying their problems, portraying the wasp nest as serving the character change), and (2) it will make the heart of your story clearer. Though the narrator seemed sheltered with the cussing and sin stuff, I didn’t think the story was about that; I especially didn’t think it was about Uncle Jim. Add more details of the characters in the beginning. Suggest Jim’s problems without the narrator knowing them (sneaking into the house, putting his belt on, spending money mysteriously). And portray the narrator’s innocence more by showing details like the Velcro watch. Bring his room up in the beginning, have him reference the shows and cartoons, have his cousin call him sheltered or make fun of his graphic tees. That will balance the story and make it truly about the characters’ relationships. The Aboutness, then, will also shine through.
I really liked your ending, at least him finding Jim’s stuff and the spoons in the toilet. If you bring this up earlier, though, perhaps having Nanny Ree ask in an early paragraph if anyone’s seen her spoons. Plant triggers like this that will lead toward later moments in the story; they make it feel complete.
I really like the complex family unit that you've created here. It seems like all the boys are almost like a bunch of misfits, and Nanny Ree holds them all together. I would like to her made more complex. Right now, we know she is kind to everyone and has some problems with Jim. Maybe if Joey saw them actually fighting up close it would make it her seem more real.
ReplyDeleteI think if your character is sixteen he needs to read a little older. I was surprised when I found out he was that old, I had placed him at around nine. Though part of me did wonder if he had a mental handicap that made him seem so young.
I think we need a little more character development and story arc here. I was confused about what the character wanted, how he grew, and what his motivation was. There were a few elements of the story that I didn't think really had much significance, like Marsha's character and their trip to their funeral. I was confused why John got so violent in the house, and why Joey got so angry in his room towards the end.
I think that if your character is going to have an accent, have it appear in the dialogue only. It's too distracting otherwise. I would also suggest changing the names of the male characters so that they all don't start with J, as they got hard to keep track of.
I really like where the story ended up, with Jim being addicted to heroine (I think it's heroine- but I know nothing about drugs). Maybe try working backwards from there and incorporating more elements of that into the story.
I think you have a great story so far. I really enjoyed reading about Nanny Ree. I think you characterized her really well. One thing I will say is that she called Johnny's dad a piece of shit and later he heard her say damn and said that was the first time he had heard her cuss, so that confused me a little. I also think that he had kind of a young sounding voice for being seventeen or sixteen. I honestly thought he was like 10-12 by the way he acted in the story. So I'd make it a little more consistent. I didn't quite understand the ending. I figured that someone was doing drugs and hiding it in the toilet, but I didn't see what exactly it had to do with the whole story. I didn't see much of a change in the story and I didn't get why it was significant. I think if you kept on after finding the drug equipment in the toilet it would make an interesting story. I also got confused on if they lived in a trailer or a house, because in the beginning it said they lived in a house, but then all of a sudden they were in a trailer.
ReplyDeleteAnd just a minor thing, I would go back and proofread because some of the grammar and punctuation was off, plus there were some words missing.
I think that the story presents a very interesting and dramatic family situation that lends itself to good conflict and strange action. Some of the details about Marsha and the drawing on the insulation of the house are really good. For the most part, dialogue is done well, such as the longer scene about cussing that develops character for Johnny and Joey. I particularly thought that the part about not being able to feel love for his cousin was strong, and the way that the narrative pressures are sort of building and constricting throughout the work creates tension and emotional power, mixed with some hilarious parts about cheese that give the work a vivid comic tinge heightened by the charismatic descriptions of Clayhatchee.
ReplyDeleteIt definitely needs rewriting on a grammatical level. Also, I can’t decide whether I like that three of the characters have “J” names. It is confusing, but funny and strange in an interesting way, too. I guess just decide what you are going for there. The way that the story switches from morning to midday and backstory for the first chunk of it clouds the conflict and scene setting. At the end we learn that the narrator is sixteen, which doesn’t feel right. All of the stuff about cussing, and his ignorance about certain events and images make him seem maybe twelve at the oldest. The overall structure of the story works, I think, but maybe one more scene at the end in a similar way that Nordan tacks on endings could work to develop the arc of your narrator and give some closure. Overall, the story has a lot of really strong characterization and setting, as well as in interesting narrative premise, but lacks specificity of intent and could use some mechanical and thematic refining, particularly around the conclusion.
Jim, Johnny, Joey. This was a little disorienting and I had to keep reminding myself who was who. Really easy to fix.
ReplyDeleteAll in all, I liked the story a lot. I loved the differences between Johnny and Joey, how one was always super sheltered and one who never had strong parenting and as a result is rebelious (and apparently a drug user).
Easily my favorite scene is the cussing scene. More about each character is revealed here than anywhere else in the story. The dialogue here is super good too.
You said you were worried about the ending being too melodramatic. I think a lot of the ending works really well, but you lost me a little bit when he threw the paint can, almost using the wasps as a weapon. I didn't find this necessary.
I liked the punching the wall (responding with violence, which was always something he could control up until this point) but I would delete, "Ahh." And then I also liked having him lock himself in the bathroom and finding the belt and spoons there. But the whole chase sequence might have been a little melodramatic.
I really enjoyed the story and want to read your revisions.